You do your best selling with no one watching, and that includes you. The craft went automatic somewhere around customer 60, you stopped noticing your own moves about then, and the people who should inherit the pitch are working from guesses. This week's issue is about putting yourself on film for once, pulling out the reads you make without thinking, and turning them into a page a new hire can run.

92% of VCs use AI to find companies. 58% of buyers start there too. If you're not showing up in AI answers, you're invisible before the conversation even starts. Join HubSpot for Startups, Anthropic, and Marketing Against the Grain on July 16 (11am ET) for a live AEO teardown. Real startup. Real recs. Register and unlock the free Startup Visibility Bundle.

Register Now

The best salesperson I ever worked with was a database engineer named Randall.

He had never carried a quota or survived a sales kickoff, and I am fairly sure he believed a pipeline was something you called a plumber about. He wore the same four flannels on a rotation you could set a calendar by, kept a whiteboard of schema diagrams no one else could read, and turned gray when a meeting ran long enough to threaten his lunch.

He had seven cats. He did not consider this a lot of cats, and if you raised the subject he would look at you the way he looked at code that shipped without tests. He was quiet most days, and then every few weeks he would announce, to no one in particular, that Gary had learned to open the pantry, and that would be the news for the month.

Selling was, by every org chart we ever drew, somebody else's job. Then we started putting him on customer calls to field the technical questions, and deals began closing in whatever room he was sitting in.

I watched one up close. A skeptical VP was 10 minutes from walking, running out the clock on objections, and our account guy, a pro who had won harder rooms than this one, was doing everything by the book and losing anyway.

Then Randall, who had said about six words all meeting, told the man the one thing our sales team would have died before saying out loud: our product would run slower than the competitor's for its first month while it learned his data, and faster than anything on the market after that.

The VP went quiet. He signed that week, and he told us later it was the only time a vendor had said something that potentially cost them money to say.

Naturally, we tried to bottle it. We sent him on more calls, and he went, with the enthusiasm of one of his cats being carried to the vet. The wins kept coming. Then we asked him to teach the trained salespeople whatever it was he was doing, and that went nowhere, because Randall could not tell us what it was.

Ask him how he closed the VP and he would shrug, say he told the guy the truth, and inevitably show you a photo of some random cat asleep in a bathroom sink. As far as he was concerned, that effectively terminated the conversation.

And now, you are Randall. Cats optional.

You founded this company, which means you served an apprenticeship in selling it that no one else was offered. You talked to the first 20 customers yourself. You heard every objection while there was still time to rebuild the product around it. You learned which hesitations were real and which were theater, which buyer needs proof and which needs permission, and somewhere near customer 60 you stopped having to think about the difference.

Of course you're the best salesperson in the building. Look at the tuition you paid.

In a narrow, specific way, the feeling that no one can sell this like you is correct. No one can.

Psychologists Paul Fitts and Michael Posner mapped what happened to you back in 1967. A skill, they found, passes through three stages on its way to mastery, and at the third, which they named the autonomous stage, it runs with almost no conscious attention left in it. A tennis player at that level serves without thinking about the serve, which frees her to plan where the return is going before the ball has crossed the net.

You are at the autonomous stage of selling your own product. The moves stopped being decisions and became reflexes, which is what lets you read the customer while everyone else in the room is still fixated on the slide deck.

That is mastery, and it comes with one strange property: the better you get, the less you can say about how.

You sit the new hire down, you open your mouth, and out comes a version so stripped down it fits on a bumper sticker. Listen more than you talk. Believe in the product. Read the room. All of it is true. None of it is teachable.

You handed her the bumper sticker, kept the car, and drove off.

The Heath brothers named this the curse of knowledge in Made to Stick: "Once we know something," they wrote, "we find it hard to imagine what it was like not to know it." You forgot how it felt to fumble a dying deal around the time you stopped fumbling them. The three reads you made before this morning's call don't feel like decisions to you anymore, so they never make it into the lesson. You skip them the way you'd skip explaining how you walk.

The new hire, meanwhile, has been writing everything down. Her notes say "read the room." She is now going to go read the wrong room, carefully, with great effort, because that page was the best material anyone gave her.

Randall hit the same wall. He said he told the guy the truth, as if that settled it, as if the rest of us had been choosing to lie. None of this is a flaw in you or in the people you've handed the selling to; it is a property of expertise itself, documented in every field anyone has bothered to study. The better the practitioner, the worse the explanation.

Meanwhile the bill arrives weekly. Deals that matter route through you, so revenue moves at the speed of one person's available hours, and that person is also building the product, running the team, and attempting sleep. You feel it the week you try to take a real vacation and can't, because three of these deals are mid-flight and you are the only licensed pilot. You feel it when a strong prospect cools off waiting for a slot on your schedule, and no one did anything wrong, and the deal dies of scheduling.

Jason Lemkin, who built and sold companies of his own before founding SaaStr, has spent years telling founders the same thing: at the start, the founder is the only person who can sell the product, because it is new and strange and short on brand, and conviction is most of the pitch.

He's right, and the phase is supposed to end. Somewhere between $200K, when you had to be in every deal, and $4 million, when you still are, the company only grows as fast as you can personally close.

So how do you get a look at a skill that runs below your own line of sight?

You can't think your way to it. You've tried, in the shower, on the drive home, and the bumper sticker comes back each time, because the part of your brain doing the selling stopped narrating the steps years ago.

Watch how anyone else recovers a skill that went automatic. A sprinter can't feel what her back foot does coming out of the blocks, so she films the start and studies the replay one frame at a time. A guitarist records the take and hears the rushed bar his hands were too busy to notice.

The move repeats across fields: get outside your own body and look at the thing from where everyone else is standing.

You have sold your product a few thousand times and studied the tape exactly … never. Zero times.

So record your next handful of real sales calls, the way the sprinter would record herself at a meet. Hunt for the moves your hands make while your mind is already three questions ahead; the script can come later.

So what do you do with the recording? I'm glad you asked.

Debrief the win out loud while someone writes it down. Right after a deal closes, walk through the replay while it's still warm. This is your post-game interview. Where did you know they were serious? Which objection did you answer before it got raised? Which prospect did you write off in the first five minutes, and what tipped you off? The person across from you has one task: keep asking "wait, why did you do that?" until the instinct turns back into a reason.

Turn the recurring moves into a plainly written motion. This is the handful of decisions you make in every deal, each with its reasoning attached: how you tell a buyer from a lookie-loo, the two or three objections that keep arriving and what dissolves them, the point where you walk away. Write the why under each one. The why is what lets the next person handle a call without needing you on speed dial.

Then hand a live deal to someone else and keep your hands in your pockets. Pick a prospect who found you cold if you can, so you learn whether the motion holds up on its own or your relationships were doing the lifting. Sit in. Say nothing. Let them lose one you might have won, and let them feel the pause you would have rushed to fill. A rescue trains the team to wait for rescues. The sale that teaches your company something is the one that closes while you're getting coffee.

Do this and the ceiling lifts. The rooms that need a founder still get you: the marquee logo, the partner deal that bends the roadmap. The 20 calls that only ever got you because there was no one else to send come off your schedule, and the skill you spent five years grinding into your bones outlives the phone call it used to die at the end of.

You become the coach, which was the promotion hiding inside the problem all along.

Randall gave notice about a year after the VP deal, on good terms, to do something none of us guessed and all of us should have.

He makes cat trees.

He builds them custom, in walnut and oak, engineered like load-bearing infrastructure, because at his house they are. There is a three-month waitlist to get one, which sounds impressive until you learn that a single tree takes him longer than three months to finish, and he only works on one at a time. The backlog is built into the manufacturing process.

The seven cats run product design but don't know it, and Gary, the tabby who once taught himself the pantry, handles anything involving a latch. (Did you know cat trees could have latches? I had no idea, either.)

Randall is doing the same thing he did in that conference room, telling people the whole truth about a thing he made and letting that do the selling, and these days there's a line for it.

Your road is shorter than his. The product exists, the skill is in your hands, the tuition is paid, and there are presumably fewer cats. All that's missing is the game film. Close the next deal like it's being recorded, because it should be, and because the person watching that tape someday won't need a lifeline that runs straight to your iPhone. Turn the camera around, and the thing you could never explain becomes the thing you get to teach.

Wispr Flow turns your voice into clean, professional text inside any app. Emails, Slack, client updates — speak once, send without editing. 4x faster than typing.

Try Wispr Flow free

Thanks for reading. See you next Wednesday.
— Jason

P.S. Hit reply and tell me: when did a deal last cool off waiting for an open slot on your calendar?